Current:Home > Contact-usWisconsin Republicans are asking a liberal justice not to hear a redistricting case-LoTradeCoin
Wisconsin Republicans are asking a liberal justice not to hear a redistricting case
View Date:2024-12-23 20:22:12
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Five of Wisconsin’s Republican members of Congress, along with the GOP-controlled Legislature, are asking the newest liberal member of the state Supreme Court not to hear a redistricting lawsuit that seeks to redraw congressional maps ahead of the November election.
The court has not yet decided whether to hear the case filed this month by the Elias Law Group, a Democratic law firm based in the nation’s capital. The court has already overturned Republican-drawn state legislative maps and is in the process of determining what the new lines will be.
The new lawsuit argues that decision last month ordering new state legislative maps opens the door to the latest challenge focused on congressional lines.
Republicans asked in that case for Justice Janet Protasiewicz to recuse herself, based on comments she made during her campaign calling the legislative maps “rigged” and “unfair.” She refused to step aside and was part of the 4-3 majority in December that ordered new maps.
Now Republicans are making similar arguments in calling for her to not hear the congressional redistricting challenge. In a motion filed Monday, they argued that her comments critical of the Republican maps require her to step aside in order to avoid a due process violation of the U.S. Constitution. They also cite the nearly $10 million her campaign received from the Wisconsin Democratic Party.
“A justice cannot decide a case she has prejudged or when her participation otherwise creates a serious risk of actual bias,” Republicans argued in the motion. “Justice Protasiewicz’s public campaign statements establish a constitutionally intolerable risk that she has prejudged the merits of this case.”
Protasiewicz rejected similar arguments in the state legislative map redistricting case, saying in October that the law did not require her to step down from that case.
“Recusal decisions are controlled by the law,” Protasiewicz wrote then. “They are not a matter of personal preference. If precedent requires it, I must recuse. But if precedent does not warrant recusal, my oath binds me to participate.”
Protasiewicz said that is the case even if the issue to be decided, like redistricting, is controversial.
“Respect for the law must always prevail,” she wrote. “Allowing politics or pressure to sway my decision would betray my oath and destroy judicial independence.”
Those seeking her recusal in the congressional redistricting case are the GOP-controlled Wisconsin Legislature and Republican U.S. Reps. Scott Fitzgerald, Glenn Grothman, Mike Gallagher, Bryan Steil and Tom Tiffany.
The only Republican not involved in the lawsuit is U.S. Rep. Derrick Van Orden, who represents western Wisconsin’s 3rd Congressional District. His is one of only two congressional districts in Wisconsin seen as competitive.
The current congressional maps in Wisconsin were drawn by Democratic Gov. Tony Evers and approved by the state Supreme Court. The U.S. Supreme Court in March 2022 declined to block them from taking effect.
The Wisconsin Supreme Court is under an extremely tight deadline to consider the challenge. State elections officials have said that new maps must be in place by March 15 in order for candidates and elections officials to adequately prepare for the Aug. 13 primary. Candidates can start circulating nomination papers on April 15.
The lawsuit argues that there is time for the court to accept map submissions and select one to be in place for the November election.
veryGood! (838)
Related
- Inter Miami's MLS playoff failure sets stage for Messi's last act, Alexi Lalas says
- Rashida Jones honors dad Quincy Jones after his death: 'Your love lives forever'
- Federal judge hears arguments in Shilo Sanders' bankruptcy case
- Mother fatally shot when moving daughter out of Iowa home; daughter's ex-boyfriend arrested
- Does your dog have arthritis? A lot of them do. But treatment can be tricky
- New York bank manager sentenced to prison for stealing over $200K from dead customer: DOJ
- This Southern Charm Star Just Announced Their Shocking Exit Ahead of Season 10
- Another Florida college taps a former state lawmaker to be its next president
- Dozens indicted over NYC gang warfare that led to the deaths of four bystanders
- 'Everything on sale': American Freight closing all stores amid parent company's bankruptcy
Ranking
- The state that cleared the way for sports gambling now may ban ‘prop’ bets on college athletes
- Florida environmental protection head quits 2 months after backlash of plan to develop state parks
- Racist text messages referencing slavery raise alarms in multiple states and prompt investigations
- Volkswagen recalls nearly 115,000 cars for potentially exploding air bag: See list here
- Army veteran reunites with his K9 companion, who served with him in Afghanistan
- Video captures mountain lion in Texas backyard; wildlife department confirms sighting
- Partial list of nominees for the 2025 Grammy Awards
- Will Smith and Jada Pinkett Smith Step Out for Dinner in Rare Public Appearance
Recommendation
-
Who's hosting 'SNL' tonight? Musical guest, start time, where to watch Nov. 9 episode
-
Taylor Swift could win her fifth album of the year Grammy: All her 2025 nominations
-
New York Post journalist Martha Stewart declared dead claps back in fiery column: 'So petty and abusive'
-
Garth Brooks Files to Move Sexual Assault Case to Federal Court
-
Chris Martin and Gwyneth Paltrow's Son Moses Martin Reveals His Singing Talents at Concert
-
Mariah Carey Shares Rare Photo of Her and Nick Cannon's 13-Year-Old Son
-
Prince William Gets Candid on Brutal Year With Kate Middleton and King Charles' Cancer Diagnoses
-
Kirk Herbstreit announces death of beloved golden retriever Ben: 'We had to let him go'